FREE Case Evaluation: 1-888-887-3117
A hernia mesh injury lawsuit is a legal claim filed by patients who suffered serious complications from defective surgical mesh implants. If you had a hernia repair with mesh after 2006 and experienced issues like chronic pain, infection, mesh migration, or required revision surgery, you may be eligible for compensation.
Major manufacturers like Atrium Medical, Ethicon, Bard/Davol, and Covidien have faced thousands of lawsuits over products such as C-QUR, Physiomesh, and the Kugel Patch. As of 2025, over 26,000 of these lawsuits are still pending in federal courts, with settlements ranging from $65,000 to over $1 million. The deadline to file, or statute of limitations, is typically 1-6 years from when you finded the injury, making timely action crucial.
Many patients, like Nancy Patterson whose mesh implant "balled up" and blocked her bowel, face unexpected and severe complications from what was supposed to be a routine repair. If you're feeling overwhelmed by medical issues and a confusing legal system, you are not alone.
I'm Tim Burd, CEO of Justice Hero. My team and I have connected thousands of people with experienced attorneys specializing in these complex cases. We are dedicated to helping clients steer the process of determining eligibility and pursuing justice against manufacturers of defective medical devices.
This guide will explain everything you need to know about hernia mesh injury lawsuits, from understanding the medical background to determining if you qualify for compensation. We'll clarify the legal process and help you make an informed decision.
To understand a hernia mesh injury lawsuit, it's helpful to know the basics of hernia repair. A hernia occurs when an organ or tissue pushes through a weak spot in the surrounding muscle, most often in the abdominal wall. The FDA provides a detailed explanation of what a hernia is and how it develops. Common types include:
Hernias do not heal on their own and typically require surgery. Surgeons perform either an open repair (one large incision) or a laparoscopic repair (several small incisions) to fix the weak area. In both procedures, surgical mesh is often used to prevent the hernia from returning.
Surgical mesh acts as a scaffold to reinforce the weakened tissue. Its use has become standard practice, featured in about 90% of the one million hernia repairs performed annually in the U.S. Studies show mesh can reduce recurrence rates by up to 50% compared to non-mesh repairs. The mesh is intended to be a permanent implant that integrates with the body's tissue.
However, while mesh was designed to improve outcomes, thousands of patients have finded that certain products are defective. These defects can lead to severe complications, chronic pain, and additional surgeries, which form the basis of hernia mesh injury lawsuits.
While many hernia mesh repairs are successful, defective products can cause debilitating problems, sometimes appearing weeks, months, or even years after surgery. Persistent post-surgery pain, swelling, or signs of infection are common red flags.
The FDA has documented numerous known complications associated with recalled and defective hernia mesh. These severe issues often form the basis of a hernia mesh injury lawsuit:
For a deeper look at these issues, see our guide on hernia mesh complications and problems.
Studies suggest that a significant number of patients—as many as 12% to 30%—experience complications. Certain materials, like non-absorbable Marlex polypropylene, have been frequently cited in lawsuits for causing severe adverse reactions. Problems can also surface long after the initial surgery, as detailed in our article on hernia mesh side effects years later.
For many, these complications necessitate one or more revision surgeries to remove or repair the defective mesh, leading to further pain, recovery time, and financial strain. If you are experiencing these symptoms, seek medical attention and document your experience, as it may be critical for a future legal claim.
A hernia mesh injury lawsuit is based on product liability law, which holds manufacturers accountable for harm caused by their products. Because thousands of patients have suffered similar injuries, these cases are often consolidated into Multidistrict Litigation (MDL). An MDL streamlines pretrial proceedings like findy and expert testimony for similar lawsuits against a single manufacturer, while still allowing each plaintiff's case to be judged on its own merits.
As of 2025, several major MDLs are active, with tens of thousands of cases pending against manufacturers like Davol/C.R. Bard (MDL 2846), Atrium (MDL 2753), and Covidien (MDL 3029). Some, like the Ethicon MDL (2782), have largely concluded through settlements.
Lawsuits typically allege one or more of the following legal claims:
Many cases use the principle of strict liability, meaning a plaintiff only needs to prove the product was defective and caused their injury, not that the company was negligent.
Several major companies are at the center of hernia mesh litigation:
A lawsuit can be valid even if the specific mesh used was not recalled. The key is proving the product was defective and caused you harm.
Determining if you can file a hernia mesh injury lawsuit involves several key factors. An attorney will evaluate your case based on common eligibility criteria to see if you have a strong claim.
Generally, you may be eligible if you meet the following conditions:
Building a strong case requires solid evidence. Your legal team will help you gather the necessary documentation, which typically includes:
A successful hernia mesh injury lawsuit can provide financial compensation for the harm you've endured. This isn't just about medical bills; it's about acknowledging the full scope of your losses, including physical pain, emotional distress, and diminished quality of life.
Damages are typically divided into three types:
While every case is unique, understanding settlement trends can provide a general idea of potential outcomes. Our guide on Hernia Mesh Lawsuit Settlements and Compensation Information offers more detail.
Average settlements often range from $65,000 to $85,000. However, cases with severe injuries, multiple revision surgeries, and permanent disability can result in awards of $1 million or more. Factors that influence the settlement amount include:
Most cases are resolved through confidential settlements. In large MDLs, manufacturers have established substantial settlement funds. For example, Becton, Dickinson and Company (parent of C.R. Bard) announced a settlement in October 2024 to resolve nearly 38,000 cases, with a reported value exceeding $1 billion.
The timeline for a settlement can vary from months to several years, as explained in our guide on how long a settlement takes. Importantly, compensation for physical injuries and pain and suffering is generally not considered taxable income by the IRS.
If you believe your complications are related to a defective hernia mesh, taking clear, decisive steps is crucial. Here is a simple guide to what you should do next.
Prioritize Your Health: See a doctor immediately for any severe or persistent symptoms like chronic pain, fever, or bowel issues. Inform them about your hernia mesh implant, as some complications can be life-threatening.
Document Everything: Keep a detailed journal of your symptoms, pain levels, and how your daily life is affected. Gather all related medical records, especially the surgical report that identifies the mesh manufacturer and product.
Do Not Sign Waivers: Avoid signing any documents from the mesh manufacturer or their representatives without consulting an attorney, as you could inadvertently waive your right to compensation.
Consult a Specialized Lawyer: The most important step is to connect with a lawyer who focuses on medical device litigation. They can provide a free case evaluation to determine if you are eligible to file a hernia mesh injury lawsuit.
At Justice Hero, our mission is to connect you with experienced Hernia Mesh Lawyers who understand these complex cases. We partner with attorneys nationwide, including in California, who work on a no-win, no-fee basis. This means you pay nothing unless they win your case, so there is no financial risk to exploring your legal options.
A specialized attorney will manage the entire legal process—from gathering evidence to negotiating with manufacturers—to fight for the compensation you deserve for your medical bills, lost wages, and pain and suffering. The manufacturers have powerful legal teams; you deserve an equally dedicated advocate. Contact Justice Hero today for a free, no-obligation case evaluation to start your path toward justice.
